Hearts, Wrapped & Ready

IT’S FREAKIN’ AWESOME - The Mix (8oz. bag)

IT’S FREAKIN’ AWESOME - The Mix (8oz. bag)

Regular price $15.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $15.00 USD
Unit price per
IT’S FREAKIN’ AWESOME - Original Mix (8oz. bag)

IT’S FREAKIN’ AWESOME - Original Mix (8oz. bag)

Regular price $15.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $15.00 USD
Unit price per
Chocolate Raspberry Heart Caramel Gift Box

Chocolate Raspberry Heart Caramel Gift Box

Regular price $15.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $15.00 USD
Unit price per
Mouth Party Caramel - OMG! 6oz gift bag

Mouth Party Caramel - OMG! 6oz gift bag

Regular price $15.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $15.00 USD
Unit price per
Mouth Party Caramel - Assorted 6oz gift bag

Mouth Party Caramel - Assorted 6oz gift bag

Regular price $15.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $15.00 USD
Unit price per
Mouth Party Caramel - Sea salt 6oz gift bag

Mouth Party Caramel - Sea salt 6oz gift bag

Regular price $15.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $15.00 USD
Unit price per
Valentine's Day Love Toffee

Valentine's Day Love Toffee

Regular price $18.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.00 USD
Unit price per
Dark Chocolate With Dried Cherries - Toffee Traditions

Dark Chocolate With Dried Cherries - Toffee Traditions

Regular price $18.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.00 USD
Unit price per
White Chocolate With Crushed Pistachios - Toffee Traditions

White Chocolate With Crushed Pistachios - Toffee Traditions

Regular price $18.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $18.00 USD
Unit price per
Valentine's 40% Milk Chocolate

Valentine's 40% Milk Chocolate

Regular price $16.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $16.00 USD
Unit price per
Valentine's 70% Dark Chocolate with Touch of Sea Salt

Valentine's 70% Dark Chocolate with Touch of Sea Salt

Regular price $16.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $16.00 USD
Unit price per
Love Gummy Mix Swedish Candy Bag

Love Gummy Mix Swedish Candy Bag

Regular price $15.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $15.00 USD
Unit price per
Stroopie Crumble Snack Mix

Stroopie Crumble Snack Mix

Regular price From $10.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $10.00 USD
Unit price per
Stroopwafel Gift Tins

Stroopwafel Gift Tins

Regular price $35.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $35.00 USD
Unit price per
Mini Stroopwafel Lollipops

Mini Stroopwafel Lollipops

Regular price $6.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $6.00 USD
Unit price per
The Perfect Pair

The Perfect Pair

Regular price $25.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $25.00 USD
Unit price per

Let customers speak for us

from 21 reviews

O&TO Is My Go To for Gifting!

O&TO is my go to for amazingly unique and fun gifts! From the curated finds to the attention to detail on the packaging, every gift is a treasure! Don’t wait, start ordering today!

Catherine

One & The Other

12/18/2025

O&TO Is My Gift Giving Go To!

O&TO is my go to for gift giving! Carolyn’s curated finds are masterfully matched to create the most unique and fun gifts. She ALWAYS delivers a thoughtful and impactful gift!

Cranberry Syrup 4oz

10/10 for kids who love airplanes

10/10 for kids who love creating paper airplanes! So easy to follow and the patterns make it extra fun!

Morgan

D.I.Y. Paper Air Planes Activity Kit - Set of 24 Designs

11/26/2025

Love this brand!

I’ve always loved this line! When I saw the oil drops I knew I immediately needed these. It’a perfect for the cooler weather and dry skin.

Velvet Droplets Nurturing Baby Bath Oil

The perfect gift box

The packaging is beautiful and makes it feel so special. It’s the gift that instantly makes you want to gather friends and pour a drink.

Margarita Señorita

The perfect round up of ribbons and things you don’t normally have on hand

The perfect round up of ribbons and things you don’t normally have on hand, to make your gift giving feel a little more personal and a little more magical. Love this product!

Emily

The Finishing Touch Kit

11/17/2025

A Ghoul-ishly Good Time!

Ghoul Fish! is an instant hit! My grandkids absolutely loved this spooky-fun card game, and we were all laughing and playing for much longer than planned. The rules are simple enough for little ones to jump right in, but still entertaining for the whole family — adults included!

It’s the perfect game to bring out during Halloween season (or anytime you want a little silly scare!). The artwork is adorable, the quality is great, and it packs just the right amount of giggles and excitement.

Highly recommend — this one’s a keeper! 🎃💜👻
— Jane

Jane

Ghoul Fish! Card Game

10/29/2025

Beautifully Curated Gifts with Heart

One & The Other is truly a treasure of a shop! Carolyn has a remarkable gift for finding unique, high-quality pieces that feel thoughtful, meaningful, and perfect for celebrating life’s special moments — big and small.

My order arrived with the most beautiful presentation and attention to detail. Everything felt curated with care and packaged with such heart. It’s so clear that Carolyn loves helping others give gifts that bring joy.

Supporting a small business like this is an absolute pleasure, and I will certainly be ordering again (and recommending One & The Other to everyone I know!). A wonderful experience from start to finish! 💛

— Jane

A Sweet Gift Every Little Girl Will Love

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I ordered the custom hand-painted barrettes for my granddaughters, and they are absolutely adorable! The girls loved them the moment they saw them. I chose to let Carolyn pick the colors and design because she has such wonderful taste — and she exceeded every expectation.

The quality is fantastic, the lettering is beautiful, and the attention to detail is just perfect. These barrettes are so sweet and special — truly the kind of accessory every little girl will want to wear! Highly recommend! 💕

Custom Hand-Painted Barrettes (set of two)

These are so cute! And they arrived very quickly which was a huge bonus.

Anonymous

10/25/2025

Easter puzzle

What a lovely puzzle - I am enjoying putting it together! Such a wonderful gift.

Vivian

Easter Greeting Puzzle

05/04/2025

I love this bag!! It is absolute adorable. So much space and tons of pockets inside.

Chelsea

"MOM" - Red Floral Jumbo Cosmetic Bag

05/01/2025

Hadley pottery bunny bank.

I love love this special, unique piece. Thank you

kim

Rabbit Bank

04/27/2025

What a special gift to receive!

"Congratulations on launching your wonderful store!!!
LOVE, LOVE, LOVE my beautifully curated gift box from Amy.
Your attention to detail is great.
I can’t wait to eat, try the lip balm and read this fun book."

Shelley

04/25/2025

Congratulations!

Love to you — you did it! So proud of you!!

Sal

04/11/2025

Item added to your cart

Collection: Hearts, Wrapped & Ready

IT’S FREAKIN’ AWESOME - The Mix (8oz. bag)

IT’S FREAKIN’ AWESOME - The Mix (8oz. bag)

IT’S FREAKIN’ AWESOME - Original Mix (8oz. bag)

IT’S FREAKIN’ AWESOME - Original Mix (8oz. bag)

Chocolate Raspberry Heart Caramel Gift Box

Chocolate Raspberry Heart Caramel Gift Box

Mouth Party Caramel - OMG! 6oz gift bag

Mouth Party Caramel - OMG! 6oz gift bag

Mouth Party Caramel - Assorted 6oz gift bag

Mouth Party Caramel - Assorted 6oz gift bag

Mouth Party Caramel - Sea salt 6oz gift bag

Mouth Party Caramel - Sea salt 6oz gift bag

Valentine's Day Love Toffee

Valentine's Day Love Toffee

Dark Chocolate With Dried Cherries - Toffee Traditions

Dark Chocolate With Dried Cherries - Toffee Traditions

White Chocolate With Crushed Pistachios - Toffee Traditions

White Chocolate With Crushed Pistachios - Toffee Traditions

Valentine's 40% Milk Chocolate

Valentine's 40% Milk Chocolate

Valentine's 70% Dark Chocolate with Touch of Sea Salt

Valentine's 70% Dark Chocolate with Touch of Sea Salt

Love Gummy Mix Swedish Candy Bag

Love Gummy Mix Swedish Candy Bag

Stroopie Crumble Snack Mix

Stroopie Crumble Snack Mix

Stroopwafel Gift Tins

Stroopwafel Gift Tins

Mini Stroopwafel Lollipops

Mini Stroopwafel Lollipops

The Perfect Pair

The Perfect Pair

Let customers speak for us